Skip to product information
1 of 1

Crispi Cookies Inc

Creamsicle Cookie Recipe

Creamsicle Cookie Recipe

5 total reviews

Regular price $3.97
Regular price Sale price $3.97
Sale Sold out

Just something about that orange & vanilla swirl! 

View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 5 reviews
80%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
A
Allison Smith
So good!

This is one of my new favorites! The topping in the recipe is not shelf stable, so I substituted homemade orange marshmallow fluff. So good! I love the texture of this one.

T
Tryn Anne

I was disappointed when I made these because the frosting pictured is nothing like the frosting recipe it actually gives. Cookie was okay

J
Jennifer Scully
Orange Creamsicle Cookies

Love, love, love this recipe. This flavor was one of my top sellers this summer. I elected to stuff them with vanilla buttercream and they were a big hit. Thank you Nicole!

E
Erin Avery
A Total Dream

This was a hit with my family and farmers market. It taste just like a Creamsicle, push pop, or orange Julius. So good. A must have recipe. Topped this one with orange flavored royal icing so it could be packaged for the market.

R
Rachael Galano
Tastes just like the ice cream!!

Soooo good 😍