Skip to product information
1 of 2

Crispi Cookies Inc

Sir Pump'king Recipe

Sir Pump'king Recipe

15 total reviews

Regular price $3.49
Regular price Sale price $3.49
Sale Sold out

The perfect introduction into the Fall season. This is a pumpkin cookie stuffed with cream cheese and topped with candied pecan streusel. These didn't last long in my house!

Upon purchase, you will be able to download at checkout. You will also receive an email with a unique download link that you can use at a later time.  

View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 15 reviews
80%
(12)
7%
(1)
7%
(1)
0%
(0)
7%
(1)
L
L.H.
Holy Crap 🤩🤩

Hands down the best pumpkin cookie of my life. The flavor is on point and the filling just throws it over the top. Pretty much in love with it.

B
B.S.

My granddaughter was so excited with this lovely cookie!! It’s become her favorite!!!

C
Cynthia (Business Upper Crust Culinary Wolf
Perfect Autumn Treat

Perfectly pumpkiny

B
Brook

Scam

B
Bethany Salomon
Judging cookies as keepers

After baking a new cookie recipe, I rate the cookie by how interesting/pretty it looks, how it tastes, its texture, how messy it is to stack and eat), how the cookie stands up after 2 days (does it get soggy or dry out when stored correctly), difficulty of the recipe, and a100% rating by family as a "keeper" to bake again (after all how many recipes become do you need as your"go-to" cookies for special occasions, holidays, and baking with the kids?).

Based on those considerations, I wasn't wowed by the look of this cookie--it looks like other fussy stuffed cookies, the cookie tastes good, but is much too sweet, but the texture was absolutely outstanding!!! My cookies were a bit flat, but were easy to stack and eat. I made these yesterday so I can't address how they stand up to the 2 day wait. This cookie recipe has multiple steps, but is not difficult to make. Family members voted that this cookie was worth making again if the sweetness factor was addressed and something was added to enhance the taste of the stuffed cream cheese. I would also like to see this cookie baked in a bun pan to make it look more interesting.

As you can see, we're tough cookie people!!! Each person gets a voice in analyzing new cookies (even the youngest grandchildren).